Dog Behaviour Problems That Are Normal Behaviours Understanding Your Dog’s Natural Instincts10/16/2026 By Norma Jeanne Laurette IntroductionA large part of what I teach in my puppy classes has nothing to do cues or signals, because it’s just as important for guardians to resolve behaviour issues while their puppies are still young. What is a behaviour problem? A behaviour problem is a normal dog behaviour that people don’t want. It’s a behaviour that’s natural to its species, and will continue unless or until the dog is taught to do something else and is motivated enough to do so. During all levels of my dog training classes I'm asked about barking, digging, chewing, jumping, chasing, pulling on leash and a variety of other behaviours that can make living with a dog challenging. What I want guardians to understand is that we don't need to stop dogs from being dogs to enjoy living with them. We need to understand what motivates their behaviour and provide appropriate outlets for their natural instincts, while teaching new behaviours to replace the ones we don’t want. Why Understanding Dog Behaviour MattersWhen we bring a puppy or adult dog into our home, we expect it to adapt to a lifestyle designed for humans. We want our dogs to stay quiet when someone walks past the house, not dig in our yard, walk beside us on a loose leash, greet visitors without jumping on them and many other behaviours that do not come naturally to a dog. These expectations are realistic however, we need to remember that dogs weren't born understanding what we want or why we want it. When we understand the motivation behind the behaviour, we're in a much better position to change it without causing unnecessary frustration, stress or anxiety for the dog (R1) R2). This is one of the reasons early positive puppy training and guided socialization is so important. The experiences puppies have during their early development will influence their temperaments, confidence, emotional responses and behaviour for the rest of their lives, and helping guardians understand normal canine behaviour is part of that process. Unfortunately, many more dogs are surrendered or euthanized every year for behaviour problems than health issues, making prevention, education and early intervention necessary for success (R10) (R11) (R12). Ten Normal Dog Behaviours Considered ProblemsBelow are ten common problems caused by normal dog behaviours, as well as explanations about how you can use appropriate outlets for the specific behaviour as part of your solution protocols. Alert BarkingDogs naturally bark to alert their social group to unfamiliar sights, sounds and smells. With a far superior sense of smell and hearing than ours, they can detect things we are not aware of (R2) (R6). When a dog repeatedly reacts to activity outside its territory, it can lead to nuisance barking. This behaviour can be controlled by teaching speak and shush as a trick, which provides a reliable on/off switch for the barking. Environmental management will help by reducing unnecessary triggers, while you provide alternative enrichment opportunities to keep the dog mentally stimulated and prevent barking. For more information about environmental management see our first book Blueprint To A Happy Dog. Digging In The Garden, Yard Or CouchDigging is a natural canine behaviour for the purpose of creating comfortable resting places, a cool place to lie on a hot day, investigating scents or burying valued resources. Some breeds have stronger digging instincts due to selective breeding, while others might imitate a person digging or simply learn that digging is fun (R2) (R7). When digging is directed toward gardens, lawns or furniture, it can become destructive. Providing a designated digging area, such as a sandbox in a kiddie pool with buried toys and treats allows dogs to satisfy their natural instincts. Meanwhile, you can use environmental management by blocking off inappropriate areas when you can’t supervision and redirecting unwanted digging when you can. Chewing Inappropriate ItemsIt’s natural for dogs to use their mouths to explore their environment, stimulate their senses, and chew to relieve boredom, frustration, stress, anxiety or excitement. Puppies especially use their mouths to investigate their world the way children use their hands (R8). When dogs chew furniture, shoes or other inappropriate items, this normal behaviour becomes destructive and potentially dangerous for the dog. Providing appealing chew toys, safe edible chews and enrichment activities that satisfy a dog’s natural need to chew can help solve this problem. Making sure the puppy or dog does not have access to inappropriate items when you can’t supervise will also help establish acceptable chewing habits. For a list of 50 canine enrichment options see my article Canine Enrichment: Best Ideas For Mental Stimulation & Boredom Prevention. Chasing Anything That MovesDogs naturally chase moving objects and animals because chasing is part of their inherited predatory behaviour sequence. Selective breeding has strengthened these instincts in certain breeds for specific purposes, making movement highly stimulating for some dogs (R2) (R6). When dogs chase wildlife, bicycles, joggers, vehicles, etc., this natural behaviour can become dangerous for the dog and in some cases, for those they chase. The solution for this problem is found in providing appropriate chase games with a reliable on/off switch, such as retrieving toys or chasing a flirt pole, which satisfies their natural instincts. Teaching a reliable recall, distraction training and environmental management to eliminated access to unsafe situations will also help prevent unwanted chasing. For more information about distraction training see my article entitled Distraction Training For Dogs: How To Teach Your Dog To Focus & Ignore Distractions. Jumping Up To Greet PeopleDogs are highly social animals and when confident and friendly, they tend to jump on people in greeting to get their attention and to get closer to their faces. When jumping is rewarded by attention, the behaviour becomes reinforced and is likely to increase in frequency (R5) (R9). Because not everyone likes being jumped on and it could cause injury if the dog jumps on a child or senior, it’s best to teach our dogs to keep their paws on the ground. This can be accomplished by satisfying the dog's desire for social interaction through teaching that calm greetings are rewarded with treats, attention and affection, but only when all four paws are on the ground. Consistent rewards for appropriate greetings will reduce jumping because the dog learns what works to get what it wants and is motivated to do so. Mouthing Or Gentle NippingIt’s natural for puppies to use their mouths to explore, play and communicate, making gentle mouthing and nipping a normal part of a puppy’s development. Being excited, frustrated, overtired or over stimulated can trigger this behaviour. When puppies direct their mouthing toward people's hands, arms or clothing, it can be painful or damage clothing. This behaviour can be changed by providing safe chew toys and edible chews, tug games with rules and other activities that satisfy their natural need for oral interaction. In this case, the puppy needs to learn that using its mouth on people ends fun and attention, while interacting without its mouth works to get the attention it values. Pulling On LeashDogs use their extraordinary sense of smell to investigate their surroundings however, they tend to move faster than humans. When pulling allows them to reach interesting scents and destinations, the behaviour becomes reinforced (R6). Although pulling is normal, it can make walks unpleasant and unsafe. Providing relaxed sniff walks that satisfy the dog’s natural urge to explore and investigate scents can help control this behaviour. Positive loose-leash training, and a comfortable front-loading harness will encourage loose leash walking without eliminating opportunities to explore. For more information about how to train your dog to walk on a loose leash see my article Pulling On Leash: How To Stop A Dog Pulling On Leash With Techniques & The Front-Loading Harness. Herding People Or Other AnimalsHerding breeds have a strong drive to chase and control movement because these instincts have been strengthened through generations of selective breeding. Circling people, blocking movement and nipping at heels are all natural expressions of inherited herding behaviour (R2) (R6). When directed toward children, visitors or other pets, these instincts can become problematic. Providing appropriate herding activities such as movement games, flirt pole games and herding balls can satisfy the dog’s natural desire to control movement, while helping to manage the unwanted behaviour. Supervision, environmental management and rewarding alternative behaviours will also help prevent inappropriate herding. Rolling In Unpleasant SmellsIt’s normal for dogs to investigate their environment through scent and part of that involves rolling in strong-smelling substances. Although researchers have offered possible explanations, the exact reason for this behaviour remains unproven (R7). One explanation is that a dog will roll in foul scents to communicate what it’s found to the rest of its social group. Another suggests that dogs roll in the scent of potential prey to be able to get closer to it without being detected. When dogs roll in animal waste, decaying animals, vegetation or other unpleasant substances, this natural behaviour can become quite unpleasant for their humans. This behaviour can be managed by providing sniff walks, scent games and other opportunities to investigate appropriate smells to satisfy their natural interest in scent exploration. Supervision, teaching a quick and reliable recall and redirecting the dog’s attention before it rolls will also help prevent scent rolling. Urine MarkingDogs communicate through scent, and urine marking allows them to leave information about their identity, sex, reproductive status, psychological and health state for other dogs to find after they leave (R20) (R21). Although outdoor marking is normal, indoor marking is a problem. This behaviour can be managed by allowing appropriate outdoor marking during walks to satisfy the dog's natural need for scent communication. Indoor supervision, thorough cleaning with a safe and appropriate ammonia-free cleaner, environmental management and positive house-training will help prevent indoor marking. With this type of behaviour, it’s always important to consult a veterinarian to rule out any underlying medical causes, as behaviour modification alone cannot resolve a problem caused by a medical condition. For a housebreaking plan see my article entitled Potty Training A Puppy: The Ultimate Step By Step Guide. The Problem With Suppressing Natural Dog BehavioursFor decades, it’s been common practice for people to reprimand or suppress unwanted behaviour without considering why the dog is engaging in it. Unfortunately, stopping the outward expression of a behaviour doesn't remove the motivation behind it. A dog that no longer engages in the behaviour may be frustrated, stressed, anxious or emotionally deprived, which in itself can lead to a myriad of other behaviour problems. Positive approaches to canine wellbeing recognize that it involves much more than just providing food, water, shelter and veterinary care. Dogs also need emotional fulfilment, which includes opportunities to engage in rewarding activities without suppressing their natural behaviours (R3) (R4). This is one reason I strongly believe in positive, reward-based, force-free dog training, because we can teach dogs how to live successfully with people without the use of pain, fear or intimidation. For more information about nurturing an emotionally healthy dog see my article Emotional Fulfilment For Dogs: How To Keep Your Dog Happy & Emotionally Balanced. Working With Your Dog's Instincts Instead Of Against ThemSupporting natural behaviour does not mean allowing dogs to do whatever they want. It means establishing reasonable boundaries while making sure all their needs are being met. It’s not possible to punish an innate motivation out of a dog, but what we can do is manage the environment to reduce opportunities for unwanted behaviour and provide appropriate outlets for their natural drives. When we approach behaviour problems this way, we're not constantly reprimanding our dogs for behaving like dogs. Instead we're meeting their needs while teaching alternative behaviours, allowing them to enjoy the natural activities that are an important part of their emotional wellbeing. For more information about solving a wide variety of behaviour problems see our second book Canine Queries. SummaryWhen we begin looking at the world through our dogs' eyes, many of the behaviours we've been calling problems start making a lot more sense. Our dogs aren't trying to make our lives difficult when they bark, dig, chew or chase, they're simply behaving like dogs, and it's our responsibility to help them express those natural instincts in ways that are appropriate. Instead of asking, "How do I stop my dog from doing this?" we can ask, "Why is my dog doing this, and how can I teach a new behaviour while still meeting my dogs’ needs?” This shift in perspective does more than change behaviour, it strengthens the bond between dogs and their people, creating a relationship built on understanding, trust, mutual respect and the freedom to be a dog. References(R1) Literature on canine problem behaviours as natural responses to environmental conditions and unmet behavioural needs, as described in the original CCS article. (R2) Ethological reviews and educational resources concerning breed-specific drives, natural instincts and canine enrichment. (R3) Mellor, D. J., et al. (2020). The 2020 Five Domains Model: Including Human–Animal Interactions in Assessments of Animal Welfare. Animals. (R4) Mellor, D. J. (2017). Operational Details of the Five Domains Model and Its Key Applications to the Assessment and Management of Animal Welfare. Animals. (R5) RSPCA and veterinary behaviour resources addressing misconceptions about canine behaviour and the welfare implications of aversive training. (R6) Reviews of evolutionary canine behavioural traits, including vigilance, predatory behaviour, herding and foraging. (R7) Studies and observational resources concerning normal behaviours in domestic and free-ranging dogs, including digging, vocalization and scent-rolling. (R8) Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2025). Research on the functional significance and welfare implications of chewing in domestic dogs. (R9) University of Bristol and related research on canine behaviour, social attachment and dominance-related misconceptions. (R10) Eagan, B. H., Gordon, E., & Protopopova, A. (2022). Reasons for Guardian-Relinquishment of Dogs to Shelters: Animal and Regional Predictors in British Columbia, Canada. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 9, 857634. (R11) Kisley, M. A., Chung, E. J., & Levitt, H. (2024). Investigating the Reasons behind Companion Animal Relinquishment: A Systematic Content Analysis of Shelter Records for Cats and Dogs, 2018–2023. Animals, 14(17), 2606. (R12) Marston, L. C., Bennett, P. C., & Coleman, G. J. (2017). Characteristics and Outcomes of Dogs Admitted into Queensland RSPCA Shelters. Animals, 7(9), 67. (R20) Siniscalchi, M., d’Ingeo, S., Minunno, M., & Quaranta, A. (2018). Communication in Dogs. Animals, 8(8), 131. (R21) McGuire, B. (2019). Urine marking in male domestic dogs: honest or dishonest? Journal of Zoology, 307, 163–170 Photo By Norma Jeanne Laurette
0 Comments
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
November 2026
Author |